27 Dec 2006 07:04 PM

Trends in Secondary Education: Specialization

by Valorie Delp | More from this Blogger

If I said that the public education at the high school level must make serious reforms--no one should be shocked. The drop out rate is at an all time high. An 8th grader 50 years ago, knew more "basics" than your average high school senior graduating today. Educators have been calling for reforms for decades.

The buzzword used to be "core knowledge". Teach all the graduating kids the same rigorous core curriculum, to bridge the knowledge gap and you'll turn out kids who are equally well prepared for college. The problem of course is who decides on what should be included in the core? Then the new buzz word became 'school choice'--give parents their choice of schools and the competition will force schools to improve. While school choice does work in many situations. . .the solution, I think, is more complicated than just implementing a 'one size fits all' plan.

Sponsors (article continues below)

The most recent trend in secondary education however is specialization: smaller high schools that teach a specialized curriculum. This allows kids to focus on things that they are really interested in, as well as get a solid foundation in the basics. New York City is a prime example of this. There are high schools that specialize in just about every thing you can think of: hospitality and tourism, health careers, culinary arts, architecture, and the performing arts just to name a few. Selection methods differ based on the school and so it's not just the elite getting into a few schools.

However, there are critics to this approach in secondary education. Some feel that specialization fails to give kids a 'common experience.' (Would it be unprofessional to interject here that I'm not sure what's so important about the common experience?) Others say that while specialization sounds great. . .it has to prove it's great on paper with high test scores, AP exams, and students graduating and going on to college.

One thing is definite: the more options that are available to parents and their kids, the more confusing it is to try to find a good fit. In looking at the Department of Education's website for New York City, I found 3 separate sites: one 47 page document explaining all of the different high schools and their 'philosophies'. I also found a separate page listing the codes used to explain how high schools selected new students. Finally I found another document that listed all the possibilities! One piece of advice for parents and kids who have the option to choose their child's high school--start early!

Related Programs:

Gifted Programs and Honors Classes

Does Your Child's School Offer Edline?

Does More Money Mean a Better Education?

Learn more about Valorie Delp

twinzplus3`s avatar

Hello everybody! My name is Valorie and I am one busy lady! When I'm not writing or editing for families, I am busy trying to get my brood of 5 in line.

View Full Profile | More from this Blogger

Send this to a friend

2 comments so far

croy (5) 13 Feb 2008 06:46 PM

The problem with specialized education is that you are presuming a 14 year old is competent to make a choice at a young age of what they would like to focus on for the rest of their life. That's not how the world works. The average job for the new generation of college grads is 3-4 years before they begin another career. In my hometown there is much talk of reforming one of the urban high schools into a vocational school. For some reason it strikes me as inherently racist to say that if you are not white and from poverty the only jobs open to you will be vocational ones. Doesn't this kind of undermine the whole purpose of education? I don't get it! The other part that makes me fume is why it is public education's job to train the factory workers of tomorrow. Can't corporate America train their own labor force. I think America works best when we have a well educated citizenry. If that is the goal then we need to teach all students how to be lifelong learners.

Valorie Delp Online! (47146) 14 Feb 2008 03:33 AM

Specialized high schools are working though. I'm not totally sure you're understanding that these high schools teach all the core subjects producing that well educated citizen that you're talking about, but the electives that students take all have to do within a certain subject matter. It's not trade school. . .it's traditional high school with a twist. But I agree that we need to produced well educated kids. Oh. . .and who said they were just for minority kids?

Discuss this article

You must be logged in to tag, rate, or comment on this item.

Not registered? Register now, it's free and only takes a minute.

Add a Comment